Browns' 2025 Rookie Class: Post-Spring Camp Impact Rankings

Following the conclusion of mandatory minicamp and OTAs, the Cleveland Browns' 2025 rookie class has begun to separate itself through early performances.

Here's how all 10 rookies - seven draft picks and three standout undrafted free agents - rank in terms of expected 2025 impact:

1. DT Mason Graham (1st Round, 5th Overall) - Highest Impact

Graham remains the clear frontrunner for immediate starting duties after dominating spring practices. "Graham lived in the backfield as a penetrating defensive lineman and Cleveland's plan is for him to be a consistent contributor to a deep and aggressive defensive line," according to draft analysis. His work alongside Myles Garrett during team drills has coaches excited about the interior pass rush potential.

The Michigan product's technique and motor have translated seamlessly to the professional level, making him the rookie most likely to influence games from Week 1.

2. QB Shedeur Sanders (5th Round, 144th Overall) - Developmental Star

Sanders has used spring practices to showcase why he was once projected much higher, displaying NFL-caliber arm strength and pocket presence.

During mandatory minicamp, "Gabriel, Pickett and Sanders each took reps during the period" in two-minute drill situations, with Sanders showing particular poise under pressure. While he won't start immediately, his development trajectory has exceeded expectations.

3. FB/TE Eli Wilson (UDFA) - Versatile Weapon Rising

The Appalachian State product has emerged as the most impressive undrafted free agent still on the roster. Wilson played 50 games at Appalachian State from 2020 to 2024, starting in 21 of them. He recorded 78 receptions for 775 yards and 12 touchdowns and earned All-Sun Belt honors in both 2023 and 2024. His receiving ability from multiple positions has created intrigue in Cleveland's offensive scheme.

His versatility as both a fullback and tight end makes him a valuable chess piece with the potential to carve out a specialized role in offensive packages.

4. LB Carson Schwesinger (4th Round) - Special Teams Standout

Schwesinger has excelled in special teams drills while showing promise in linebacker packages. His athleticism and football IQ have impressed coaches during the voluntary and mandatory sessions, positioning him as a key contributor on coverage units with rotational defensive upside.

5. QB Dillon Gabriel (3rd Round) - Steady Veteran Presence

Gabriel has provided exactly what the Browns expected—steady, experienced quarterback play. His extensive college background shows during practice, though his ceiling appears limited compared to Sanders' explosive potential. Gabriel continues competing for the backup role behind the established starter.

6. RB Quinshon Judkins (4th Round) - Crowded Backfield

Despite his college production, Judkins faces an uphill battle in a crowded running back room. His physical style should earn him short-yardage opportunities, but spring practices haven't provided clear separation from other depth options.

7. S Donovan McMillon (UDFA) - Safety Development

Cleveland loves to find and develop UDFA safeties (D'Anthony Bell, Ronnie Hickman, Chris Edmonds), and it wouldn't be surprising to see Donovan McMillon be the team's 2025 iteration. McMillon represents the Browns' continued investment in developing undrafted defensive backs.

8. RB Dylan Sampson (Late Round) - Long Shot

Sampson's odds of making the active roster remain slim following spring practices. The depth at running back makes his development more of a long-term project than an immediate contributor.

9. TE Harold Fannin Jr. (Late Round) - Practice Squad Candidate

Fannin continues developing his route-running and blocking fundamentals. "Former coaches describe Harold Fannin Jr. as big-time," but his path to meaningful contributions appears limited given Cleveland's tight end depth.

10. WR LaMareon James (UDFA) - Camp Competitor

James has shown flashes during spring practices but needs a strong training camp to make the roster. His speed provides intrigue, though consistency remains a concern among a deep receiving corps.

Spring Assessment

The Browns have added depth and competition to their roster by signing 13 undrafted free agents, including five defensive players, seven offensive players, and one specialist.

The focus now shifts to training camp, where these rookies will compete for final roster spots. Among the newcomers, Graham stands out with his potential for an immediate impact, while Sanders offers intriguing long-term developmental promise. Together, this rookie class could contribute both short-term benefits and a solid foundation for the team's future.